The Broken Girls – Guilt, Ghosts, and Buried Secrets: A Detailed Review of Simone St. James’s Audiobook

1. About the Author: Simone St. James

Simone St. James is a prominent author in the mystery and supernatural suspense genre. She began her career with gothic-inspired novels like The Haunting of Maddy Clare (winner of the 2012 RITA Award), and has since established herself with emotionally rich storytelling, deeply drawn characters, and haunting atmospheres. Her signature style blends dual timelines, psychological depth, and ghostly elements, earning critical acclaim and a loyal fan base worldwide.

2. About the Narrator: Rebecca Lowman

Rebecca Lowman is one of the most beloved female narrators on Audible. Known for her performances in titles like Eleanor & Park and Everything I Never Told You, Lowman’s voice is praised for its calm tone, emotional nuance, and seamless delivery. In The Broken Girls, she masterfully brings to life two timelines and multiple character arcs with a haunting performance that perfectly matches the story’s chilling undertones.

3. About the Book: The Broken Girls

The Broken Girls is a chilling mystery novel infused with supernatural elements. The story is set around Idlewild Hall, a boarding school for “troubled” girls in 1950, and alternates with a 2014 timeline where journalist Fiona Sheridan investigates the murder of her sister, whose body was found near the abandoned school grounds. As Fiona digs deeper, she unearths secrets that tie the school’s dark past to present horrors.

The novel stands out due to its dual timeline structure, its exploration of forgotten women, and its seamless blend of thriller and ghost story elements. On Goodreads, the book holds a strong 4.06-star rating from over 120,000 reviews, and on Audible, the audiobook receives 4.4 out of 5 stars from over 8,000 listeners. This is widely considered one of Simone St. James’s best post-Haunting of Maddy Clare works.

4. Book Review: The Broken Girls

The Broken Girls is an atmospheric and emotionally resonant story that fuses psychological suspense with ghostly horror. Simone St. James’s writing is compelling and layered, slowly peeling back secrets that have been buried for decades.

Strengths:

• Rich dual-timeline structure that flows seamlessly.

• Complex characters, particularly the 1950s schoolgirls.

• Strong themes of trauma, recovery, and forgotten voices.

• A perfectly eerie, gothic atmosphere.

Weaknesses:

• The ending may feel slightly rushed.

• Some side characters lack full development.

“A haunting and poignant ghost story, told with elegance.” — Crime by the Book

“St. James once again proves she’s the queen of modern gothic suspense.” — Publishers Weekly

Personal Thoughts:

I was deeply impressed by how The Broken Girls transports the reader between time periods, weaving real pain and supernatural elements into a gripping narrative. This book is not just a mystery—it’s a powerful reminder of those society forgets. I couldn’t stop listening. It felt like the haunted halls of Idlewild Hall were calling me into the shadows, one secret at a time.

5. Audiobook Review: The Broken Girls (Narrated by Rebecca Lowman)

Rebecca Lowman’s narration elevates The Broken Girls to another level. Her performance breathes life into each character, distinguishing their voices and emotional tones with expert subtlety. Her pacing and control help sustain the eerie tension throughout the entire story.

Pros:

• A calm yet emotionally rich delivery.

• Excellent voice modulation for dual timelines.

• Skillful portrayal of inner monologues and suspense.

Cons:

• A slower pace in the beginning may not suit all listeners.

“Lowman delivers a hypnotic, spine-tingling performance.” — AudioFile Magazine

“She doesn’t just narrate—she embodies the atmosphere.” — Booklist

Personal Thoughts:

For me, The Broken Girls in audiobook form is even more impactful than in print. Rebecca Lowman’s voice pulled me into the story’s foggy landscapes and haunted dorms. I felt every whisper, every chill, and every buried truth. It’s one of those audiobooks that you can’t—and won’t—pause.

6. Who Should Read or Listen to This Book?

The Broken Girls is an excellent choice for:

• Fans of psychological thrillers and gothic suspense.

• Readers who enjoy dual timelines and dark family secrets.

• Anyone intrigued by female-centered mysteries and supernatural elements.

• Newcomers to Audiobooks—Lowman’s clear delivery makes it accessible and engaging.

If you loved The Girl on the Train or The Silent Patient, The Broken Girls should be at the top of your to-read or to-listen list.

7. Conclusion

The Broken Girls by Simone St. James is more than just a suspense novel—it’s a ghost story rooted in emotional truth. With unforgettable characters, atmospheric storytelling, and an outstanding audiobook performance by Rebecca Lowman, this title deserves a spot on your bookshelf or your earbuds.

If you’re seeking an audiobook that is gripping, eerie, and emotionally moving, The Broken Girls is your next best listen.

8. Where to Listen to the Audiobook

#CommissionsEarned
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

You can listen on the following platforms:

• Audiobooks.com – Stream or download, with a free first book for new members.

• Audible – Free trial available with offline listening support.

We recommend signing up for a membership to enjoy seamless access to this and many other high-quality audiobooks anytime, anywhere.