1. About the Author: Drew Strickland – A Promising Voice in Crime Fiction
Drew Strickland is an American author known for crafting atmospheric and emotionally charged crime thrillers. His storytelling often centers around small-town communities, where deep secrets simmer beneath seemingly tranquil surfaces. With Buried in the Backwater, Strickland launches the Sheriff Elven Hallie series, introducing a compelling new protagonist and showcasing his talent for layered mystery plots and morally complex characters.
Strickland has previously written other thrillers such as Death in the Dark Water and Hunted on the High Ridge, gaining recognition for his gripping narratives and understated yet intense prose style. His work resonates with fans of Joe Pickett, Longmire, and other rural procedural series.
2. About the Narrator: Madison Niederhauser – A Voice That Embodies the Sheriff
Madison Niederhauser is a professional audiobook narrator with a strong track record in the thriller and suspense genres. His cool, deep-toned delivery brings gravitas and authenticity to the character of Sheriff Elven Hallie.
Listeners have praised Niederhauser’s voice as perfectly matching the tone of the story — steady, calm, yet filled with emotional undercurrents. He adeptly conveys tension, suspicion, and subtle power dynamics, making him a strong asset to the audiobook version of this title.
3. About the Book: Buried in the Backwater – A Mystery in the Heart of a Quiet Town
In Buried in the Backwater, a teenage boy is found dead in a murky backwater in a seemingly quiet town. Newly appointed Sheriff Elven Hallie must navigate a community divided by class, old grudges, and unspoken truths. As he delves deeper into the investigation, Elven uncovers a network of lies, suppressed guilt, and simmering danger.
The novel combines murder mystery, psychological suspense, and rural noir, making it a gripping first entry into a promising new series.
-
Genre: Crime Thriller / Murder Mystery / Small-Town Suspense
-
Average Ratings:
-
Goodreads: 4.1/5 (1,000+ reviews)
-
The StoryGraph: 3.6/5
-
-
Awards: None (as of now)
-
Notable Mentions: Recognized by multiple book blogs as “a dazzling debut with a killer twist.”
The setting, reminiscent of Mare of Easttown or Wind River, gives the novel a raw, emotional grounding that elevates it beyond the usual whodunit formula.
4. Book Review: Secrets Drown Slowly in Still Water
Overall Impression
Buried in the Backwater offers a taut, twisty narrative with well-structured pacing and atmospheric depth. The protagonist, Sheriff Elven, is both stoic and quietly haunted — a perfect lens through which readers explore a town riddled with buried secrets.
While the plot is fast-paced and engaging, some readers have noted that side characters feel underdeveloped, and the ending, though surprising, may feel abrupt to some. However, for fans of dark thrillers with a steady buildup, this book delivers.
“Strickland dazzles in this series debut with quite the twist at the end!” – Pechey Ponderings
“Dark, mysterious, fast-paced and immersive.” – StoryGraph reviewer
Personal Reflection
This book had me hooked from the very first chapter. Strickland’s depiction of small-town life, where everyone knows your name — and your secrets — felt strikingly real. The mystery unfolds with just the right amount of tension, and the way Elven navigates the layers of deceit made me constantly question every character. While the ending caught me off guard, it was the quiet melancholy of the sheriff’s journey that stayed with me. If you’re looking for a story that grips you emotionally while delivering a strong mystery, this book should be on your radar.
5. Audiobook Review: A Performance That Enhances the Mystery
Madison Niederhauser’s performance in the audiobook version of Buried in the Backwater adds a layer of authenticity and emotional resonance. His deep voice gives Sheriff Elven a palpable presence, and his delivery style — calm, controlled, yet expressive — mirrors the tension of the unfolding plot.
While some listeners found his tone a bit too nasal at times, the majority appreciated the natural pacing and how he made characters distinct without overacting.
“The narrator has just the right voice for this story… smooth, cool, and oozing handsomeness.” – The StoryGraph
“A great performance. Brought the characters to life and maintained the mood throughout.” – Audible Listener Review
Personal Reflection
Listening to the audiobook was like stepping into a movie. Niederhauser doesn’t just narrate — he inhabits the character of Elven Hallie. The slow, deliberate cadence he uses amplifies the suspense, making even mundane moments feel charged. I often paused and rewound certain scenes, not because I missed them, but because I wanted to relive the mood. For someone who listens to dozens of thrillers a year, this was one of the more immersive performances I’ve experienced recently.
6. Who Should Listen to or Read This Book?
-
Fans of small-town crime mysteries
-
Thriller lovers looking for a new series
-
Audiobook enthusiasts who appreciate slower, atmospheric pacing
-
Readers who enjoy morally gray characters and layered backstories
-
Newcomers to crime fiction — the plot is accessible without being simplistic
If you enjoy titles like Longmire, True Detective, or CJ Box’s Joe Pickett series, Buried in the Backwater will feel like a natural fit. It’s also great for those dipping their toes into the audiobook format thanks to its steady narration and immersive world-building.
7. Conclusion: Why Buried in the Backwater Belongs on Your Must-Listen List
Drew Strickland’s Buried in the Backwater is a strong and atmospheric debut that offers a tightly plotted mystery, memorable characters, and an evocative setting. Coupled with Madison Niederhauser’s gripping narration, the audiobook elevates the story to a cinematic experience.
Whether you’re looking for your next binge-worthy listen or a quiet evening read that keeps you guessing, this book delivers. Add it to your list now — and prepare to be submerged in secrets.
8. Where to Listen to the Audiobook
#CommissionsEarned
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
You can listen on the following platforms:
We recommend signing up for a membership to enjoy seamless access to this and many other high-quality audiobooks anytime, anywhere.
Reviews
There are no reviews yet.