1. About the Author: J. D. Robb
J. D. Robb is the famous pen name of American novelist Nora Roberts, one of the most successful and influential commercial fiction writers of the modern era. While Nora Roberts is best known for romance, romantic suspense, and emotionally driven stories about relationships, the J. D. Robb name is closely associated with a futuristic world of crime, advanced technology, and complex police investigations led by Lieutenant Eve Dallas in the In Death series.
The In Death series began with Naked in Death and gradually expanded into a large fictional universe consisting of dozens of novels, novellas, and connected stories. Books such as Naked in Death, Glory in Death, Immortal in Death, Rapture in Death, Conspiracy in Death, Witness in Death, Portrait in Death, New York to Dallas, and Big Jack have helped establish J. D. Robb’s recognizable style.
One of the defining characteristics of J. D. Robb’s writing is her ability to combine several genres within a single story. An In Death novel can simultaneously contain elements of police procedural, mystery, thriller, science fiction, romance, and character drama. The crimes usually drive the plot forward, but the long-term development of the recurring characters is what keeps many readers returning to the series.
Eve Dallas is a perfect example. She is not simply a cold, brilliant detective who exists to solve puzzles. Eve has a complicated past, deep psychological scars, a blunt communication style, and a very strong moral code. Around her are Roarke, Peabody, Feeney, McNab, Mavis, Summerset, and many other recurring characters. Over the course of the series, they form a world that feels less like a rotating cast of mystery characters and more like a group of familiar people readers are returning to visit.
J. D. Robb’s writing is also known for fast, sharp dialogue and frequent humor, even in the middle of serious situations. The balance between murder, emotion, romance, and witty exchanges helps distinguish In Death from more conventional crime series.
In Big Jack, these strengths remain present, but the story also introduces a multigenerational mystery structure. A diamond robbery from the past becomes the foundation of a new criminal investigation in the future, creating something that feels like a treasure mystery, cold case, and murder investigation combined.
2. About the Narrator: Susan Ericksen
Susan Ericksen is one of the narrators most closely associated with the In Death Audiobook series. For many longtime listeners, her voice has effectively become part of the identity of the series. Eve Dallas, Roarke, Peabody, and other recurring characters do not simply exist on the page; through Ericksen’s performance, they develop distinct voices and personalities.
Her greatest strength is character differentiation. In an Audiobook with many characters appearing in rapid dialogue exchanges, a narrator has to make it clear who is speaking without forcing the listener to rely constantly on phrases such as “he said” or “she said.” Ericksen handles this particularly well.
Eve Dallas is usually performed with a clipped, quick, blunt, and slightly sardonic tone. It fits a police lieutenant who dislikes wasting time and tends to approach the world with direct practicality. When Eve becomes vulnerable or reveals emotions tied to her traumatic past, Ericksen does not dramatically alter the voice. Instead, she uses subtle changes in pacing, volume, and emotional intensity.
Peabody has a completely different personality. Her voice carries more visible energy and emotional reaction, which makes conversations between Peabody and Eve one of the most entertaining sources of humor in the Audiobook.
Roarke is considerably more difficult to perform because Ericksen must portray a charismatic Irish man while maintaining a distinct accent. Her Irish accent for Roarke is noticeable and has become one of the more debated elements of her narration. Many fans love the interpretation, while some listeners who are particularly sensitive to accents may need time to adjust.
Another advantage Susan Ericksen brings is her performance background. She does not merely read J. D. Robb’s sentences accurately. She uses pacing, pauses, emphasis, and shifts in intensity to support the story. Investigative scenes become focused and urgent, humorous exchanges benefit from careful comic timing, and suspense sequences gain tension without feeling excessively dramatized.
This is one of the major reasons why the Big Jack Audiobook offers a somewhat different experience from the printed or digital edition. The listener is not simply following a mystery but hearing what often feels like a one-person dramatic production containing an entire cast of characters.
3. About Big Jack
Big Jack is part of J. D. Robb’s In Death universe and is generally positioned around #17.5 in the series chronology. However, understanding its publication structure is important: Big Jack originally appeared as the J. D. Robb portion of the novel Remember When.
The earlier part of the story begins in Hot Rocks, focusing on Laine Tavish, Max Gannon, Big Jack O’Hara, and the history of a major diamond robbery. Decades later, Big Jack brings that mystery into Eve Dallas’s world.
The main setting is New York City in 2059, a future in which technology has advanced dramatically but greed, violence, and criminal behavior remain very human. Diamonds stolen many years ago were never completely recovered. When the unresolved past begins to result in murders in the present, Eve Dallas and her team must determine what really happened and who is willing to kill in order to claim the remaining fortune.
In terms of genre, Big Jack can be described as a mixture of mystery, crime thriller, police procedural, romantic suspense, and science fiction. Compared with In Death novels centered on serial killers or psychologically brutal crimes, Big Jack feels more like a treasure hunt combined with a cold case.
Major themes include greed, the long-term consequences of crime, the influence of the past on the present, and the way buried secrets can return decades later. The novel also continues to explore loyalty, partnership, and the evolving relationships within Eve’s investigative team.
On Goodreads, Big Jack has maintained an average rating of roughly 4.2 out of 5 based on more than 13,000 ratings in the commonly cited review data. That represents a strong reception for a work occupying an unusual position within such a long-running series.
Reliable standalone sales figures for Big Jack are not widely available, partly because the story was also published as part of Remember When. Likewise, Big Jack is not generally promoted as a major award-winning standalone novel. Its significance comes primarily from its place within the In Death universe and from the positive response of longtime readers.
What makes Big Jack especially distinctive is its mystery across time. Readers are not simply asking, “Who committed the murder?” They are also discovering how an old robbery created consequences that continued into Eve Dallas’s future.
4. Big Jack Book Review
If Big Jack had to be described in one sentence, it would be a classic In Death crime novel infused with a strong treasure-mystery atmosphere. Instead of beginning with a new serial killer or a completely isolated murder, J. D. Robb builds the story around missing diamonds and a secret that has survived across generations.
Plot and Mystery
The first major strength in this Big Jack Review is its immediately engaging premise.
A diamond robbery occurred.
Much of the fortune disappeared.
Years passed.
But the story was never truly finished.
When people in the present begin dying because of the remaining diamonds, Eve Dallas is forced to reconstruct events she never witnessed.
This creates two layers of mystery. Eve must investigate current crimes while also understanding what really happened decades earlier. The investigation therefore feels like assembling two different puzzles and discovering where their pieces overlap.
However, this is not a thriller that relies entirely on shocking twists. Experienced mystery readers may anticipate some of the directions the plot takes. The stronger appeal lies in watching Eve gather evidence, connect details, question assumptions, and gradually reconstruct the truth.
Characters
As with many books in the In Death series, the characters may ultimately be more memorable than the mystery itself.
Eve remains at the center of the story. She is direct, dry, intensely serious about her job, and often placed alongside characters whose personalities are completely different from hers.
Peabody is one of the highlights of Big Jack. At this stage in the series, the Eve–Peabody relationship is evolving from a straightforward boss-subordinate structure into something closer to a true investigative partnership. Peabody is no longer simply following instructions; she is developing her own identity as an investigator.
These moments are especially rewarding for readers following the series in order because they have already witnessed Peabody’s growth over multiple books.
Roarke continues to play an important role both emotionally and within the investigative dynamic. J. D. Robb has long been effective at preventing the Eve–Roarke relationship from becoming a separate romantic subplot disconnected from the crime story. Roarke is regularly integrated into Eve’s investigative world, allowing her professional and personal lives to intersect naturally.
Writing Style
One reason the In Death series has remained popular for so long is J. D. Robb’s ability to maintain momentum.
Chapters frequently move between investigation, interrogation, forensic details, personal conversations, and witty banter. This keeps the novel from becoming overloaded with police dialogue or procedural exposition.
Humor is also important. Eve often delivers completely serious statements in ways that provoke reactions from Peabody or Roarke, resulting in dialogue that feels both natural and entertaining.
This is also one of the areas where the Audiobook format becomes especially effective because much of the humor depends on timing and delivery.
Weaknesses of Big Jack
The biggest weakness of Big Jack is its connection to Hot Rocks and Remember When.
Readers can still understand the core plot without reading the earlier story, but part of the emotional payoff is lost. The people and events from the past become much more meaningful when the audience already understands the earlier stage of the diamond mystery.
Another limitation is that the crime is not exceptionally difficult to predict compared with the strongest mysteries in the In Death series. Readers looking primarily for extreme plot twists may not consider this J. D. Robb’s most challenging mystery.
Some longtime readers have also noticed minor continuity inconsistencies with surrounding installments. These do not seriously damage the plot but may stand out to people reading the series consecutively.
Personal Thoughts
In my view, the strongest reason to read Big Jack is not that it is J. D. Robb’s most complicated mystery, but that it turns a diamond robbery from the past into a crime story stretching across generations. As Eve Dallas begins connecting old evidence with new murders, the past and present gradually begin to overlap. For readers already invested in Eve, Roarke, and Peabody, the experience becomes even richer because the relationships between these characters give the story emotional depth that a standalone thriller might struggle to achieve.
5. Big Jack Audiobook Review
The Big Jack Audiobook is a clear example of how narration can significantly change the experience of the same story.
Susan Ericksen does not simply read J. D. Robb’s text aloud. She gives each major character a distinct rhythm, tone, and personality. In a dialogue-heavy novel like Big Jack, that makes a substantial difference.
Eve Dallas
Susan Ericksen portrays Eve with a clipped, direct, and often sardonic cadence. When Eve is interrogating a suspect or dealing with an investigative problem, her voice sounds focused and decisive.
More importantly, Eve’s vulnerable moments are handled without excessive dramatization. Ericksen usually changes only the pacing, volume, or length of pauses, allowing the listener to recognize Eve’s emotional shift without making her sound like a completely different person.
Peabody
Peabody is one of the most enjoyable voices in the production.
Compared with Eve, Peabody has greater emotional variation. When the two characters speak together, their voices are different enough that the listener can follow the exchange easily.
That is particularly useful in Big Jack, because the developing Eve–Peabody partnership is one of the story’s notable character elements.
Ericksen also uses comedy timing effectively. A line that may appear only mildly humorous on the page can become much funnier when Eve delivers it with total seriousness and Peabody reacts in a completely different emotional register.
Roarke
Roarke is probably the most divisive voice.
Susan Ericksen gives him a clearly recognizable Irish accent, and for many longtime In Death Audiobook fans, that interpretation has become inseparable from the character.
However, accents are highly subjective. Some listeners who are particularly sensitive to Irish pronunciation or accustomed to a different interpretation may require time to adjust.
This is less a technical weakness than a matter of personal preference.
Character Differentiation
This is Susan Ericksen’s greatest strength.
Eve, Roarke, Peabody, and the supporting characters differ not only in pitch but also in cadence, energy level, and emotional response.
As a result, the Audiobook sometimes feels surprisingly close to a small-scale radio drama even though it is performed by a single narrator.
Reviews of the narration for Remember When and Big Jack are generally positive, with some Audiobook-focused reviews rating Susan Ericksen’s performance above 4 out of 5. Among longtime In Death listeners, comments about her ability to “bring the characters to life” are especially common.
There is no single official aggregate critics’ score dedicated solely to the narration of Big Jack, since major Audiobook platforms rely primarily on user ratings rather than a Metacritic-style system. Nevertheless, listener sentiment is broadly positive, particularly regarding voice differentiation and character performance.
Weaknesses of the Audiobook
The main drawbacks are largely matters of personal preference rather than technical quality.
Some listeners may dislike Roarke’s accent.
Listeners unfamiliar with Susan Ericksen may also need several chapters to become accustomed to the established voices she uses throughout the series.
In addition, because Big Jack belongs to a world filled with recurring characters, complete newcomers may sometimes feel as though they have walked into a group of people who already know each other extremely well.
For longtime In Death Audiobook listeners, however, this is exactly part of the appeal.
Personal Thoughts on the Audiobook
In my view, if you decide to experience Big Jack, the Audiobook narrated by Susan Ericksen is well worth considering. The mystery itself is entertaining, but it is the exchanges between Eve, Peabody, Roarke, and the supporting cast that give the story much of its personality. Ericksen makes those conversations considerably more vivid through strong voice differentiation and timing. For listeners who enjoy Audiobooks while driving, exercising, doing household tasks, or relaxing, Big Jack has a pace that is clear and energetic enough to remain engaging over extended listening sessions.
6. Who Should Read Big Jack?
Big Jack is not limited to one type of reader. Its combination of mystery, crime, science fiction, and character drama makes it suitable for several audiences.
First, it is especially appropriate for fans of the In Death series. Readers who already know Eve Dallas, Roarke, and Peabody will gain more from the subtle developments in their relationships.
Those following the chronology should ideally approach Big Jack after becoming familiar with Hot Rocks or by reading the complete Remember When. The diamond mystery feels much more complete when experienced in that order.
The second group is readers who enjoy police procedurals but do not necessarily want an extremely dark story. Big Jack contains murder, investigation, and suspense, but the missing-diamond premise gives the story a treasure-mystery quality that makes it feel somewhat lighter than many other In Death installments.
The third group is readers who enjoy character-driven crime fiction. If you care as much about relationships and recurring characters as you do about solving the crime, J. D. Robb is particularly well suited to that preference.
Fans of romantic suspense may also enjoy the Eve–Roarke relationship. However, the romance does not dominate the novel. It runs alongside the investigation and functions as part of the characters’ lives rather than as a separate storyline.
For Audiobook listeners, Big Jack is even more attractive. Susan Ericksen provides a listening experience that differs significantly from reading the ebook or print edition. If you enjoy narrators who strongly differentiate characters and use a degree of voice acting, this Audiobook is a good match.
On the other hand, if you are looking exclusively for a completely standalone mystery and know nothing about In Death, Big Jack may not be the ideal starting point. You can still understand the central story, but the character development will carry more meaning if you already know the series.
7. Conclusion: Is Big Jack Worth Reading and Listening To?
Big Jack is an intriguing entry in J. D. Robb’s In Death universe because it does more than investigate a crime occurring in the present. It connects Eve Dallas’s investigation to a mystery that began decades earlier.
The missing diamonds provide the initial hook, but the book’s lasting appeal comes from the familiar qualities that have made the series successful: Eve Dallas, Roarke, Peabody, methodical investigation, sharp dialogue, and the balance between suspense and humor.
In terms of plot, Big Jack may not be J. D. Robb’s most unpredictable mystery, but its multigenerational cold-case structure gives the book a distinct identity.
In terms of characterization, it is particularly worthwhile for readers following the development of Eve and Peabody.
In terms of the Audiobook, Susan Ericksen once again demonstrates why so many fans associate her voice with In Death. Her voice differentiation, pacing, and dialogue delivery make the story vivid and easy to follow.
If you have already read Hot Rocks or are following In Death in order, Big Jack is a natural continuation that should not be skipped. If you are completely new to the series, you can still enjoy the story, though the experience will be richer if you first understand a little about Eve Dallas and her world.
For readers who enjoy crime fiction, mystery, romantic suspense, and especially Audiobooks with strong character-focused narration, Big Jack deserves a place on the reading or listening list.
8. Where to Listen to the Audiobook
#CommissionsEarned
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
You can listen on the following platforms:
We recommend signing up for a membership to enjoy seamless access to this and many other high-quality audiobooks anytime, anywhere.
Reviews
There are no reviews yet.