“Murder on Waverly Place” – Séance Secrets and a Chilling Investigation | Intense Audiobook Review of Victoria Thompson’s Mystery

1. About the Author: Victoria Thompson

Victoria Thompson is a prominent figure in historical mystery fiction in the United States. She is best known for her Gaslight Mysteries series, with Murder on Waverly Place being the 11th installment. Thompson’s writing career is rooted in her deep historical knowledge and her skill in crafting suspenseful, engaging narratives. Her stories often revolve around New York City in the late 19th century, featuring characters such as midwife-turned-sleuth Sarah Brandt and police sergeant Frank Malloy. Her narrative style is praised for being both structurally tight and rich in period detail, captivating both casual readers and critics alike.

2. About the Narrator: Suzanne Toren

Suzanne Toren is a seasoned voice actress well-loved in the audiobook community. With her warm, expressive voice and versatility in portraying a wide range of characters, she has played a key role in the success of many audiobooks, especially in the historical and mystery genres. In Murder on Waverly Place, Toren brings to life the assertive voice of Sarah Brandt, the gruff tone of Sergeant Malloy, and the eerie atmosphere of the séance with finesse. Her professional delivery and emotional nuance make this audiobook particularly immersive and enjoyable.

3. Book Overview: Murder on Waverly Place

Murder on Waverly Place is a historical mystery novel, part of the Gaslight Mysteries series. The story unfolds in late-19th-century New York, where midwife Sarah Brandt and Sergeant Frank Malloy investigate a strange murder that takes place during a séance. Everyone present is holding hands at the moment of the crime, making the mystery all the more baffling. The novel stands out for blending suspense, supernatural elements, and richly detailed historical settings.

The audiobook runs approximately 9 hours and 30 minutes. According to Audible, the book has an average rating of 4.3/5 stars from hundreds of listeners. While it hasn’t won any major awards, it remains one of the most well-loved titles in the Gaslight series.

4. Book Review: Murder on Waverly Place

Murder on Waverly Place reaffirms Victoria Thompson’s strength in constructing compelling mysteries. One of the novel’s greatest strengths is its unique séance setting—a refreshing and suspenseful twist not often seen in detective fiction. The plot is well-paced, the characters are multidimensional, and the historical setting feels authentic and alive.

Some readers might find the culprit predictable, and the early chapters progress a bit slowly. However, Thompson’s steady hand and clever plotting make it worthwhile till the end.

Notable Quotes from Reviews:

“Clever plotting, and the hint of the supernatural … make this page‑turner a must for both fans and readers new to the series.” – Blackstone Library

Personal Thoughts:

I was instantly drawn in by the séance scene—it’s eerie and sets a gripping tone. Even though I’ve read many mysteries, few start with such a spooky and well-crafted setup. For me, this book strikes the perfect balance between entertainment and atmosphere. It’s a must-read for fans of historical mysteries with a twist.

5. Audiobook Review: Suzanne Toren’s Performance

The Murder on Waverly Place audiobook, narrated by Suzanne Toren, is an excellent pick for those who appreciate professional, emotive narration. Toren masterfully distinguishes between characters with nuanced voice modulation, making the story feel vivid and alive. Key scenes—especially the séance and investigative dialogues—are brought to life with dramatic flair.

Some listeners noted that her pace quickens unexpectedly at times, and certain elderly character voices felt exaggerated. However, these are subjective impressions and vary between listeners.

Critic Quotes:

“I enjoy listening to Suzanne Toren narrate this series. She does an excellent job bringing me into the story.” – Audible Listener

“A beautifully narrated audiobook that captures the mysterious mood of a bygone era.” – Kirkus Reviews

Personal Thoughts:

I listened to this audiobook over several evenings and felt transported to an eerie, gas-lit New York. Suzanne Toren’s voice doesn’t just tell a story—it creates a cinematic experience. Her performance added depth to the characters and atmosphere, making it much more than just a typical mystery read.

6. Who Should Read This Book?

Murder on Waverly Place is a perfect match for:

• Fans of historical detective fiction set in early 20th-century New York

• Readers who enjoy locked-room or séance-themed mysteries

• Audiobook lovers looking for immersive narration and intelligent storytelling

• Long-time followers of the Gaslight Mysteries series, or newcomers looking for a standalone entry point

The book’s rich blend of mystery, supernatural intrigue, and historical accuracy offers something for everyone—from genre enthusiasts to casual listeners seeking a gripping story.

7. Conclusion

Murder on Waverly Place by Victoria Thompson is a captivating historical mystery—thanks to its suspenseful plot, unique setting, and authentic characters. The audiobook version, brilliantly narrated by Suzanne Toren, elevates the experience to another level. Whether you’re an audiobook aficionado or a historical fiction lover, this title deserves a spot on your playlist or bookshelf.

Let yourself be swept into the cobblestone streets of old New York, where secrets hide in the shadows and danger lurks even in the most spiritual of gatherings.

8. Where to Listen to the Audiobook

#CommissionsEarned
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

You can listen on the following platforms:

• Audiobooks.com – Stream or download, with a free first book for new members.

• Audible – Free trial available with offline listening support.

We recommend signing up for a membership to enjoy seamless access to this and many other high-quality audiobooks anytime, anywhere.